The players to a man gave 100% their pain, so much greater that the fans, will be physical as well as emotional, over the next few days. Kiefer Moore, kicked, punched and constantly abused by Polish defenders and never afforded a moment of protection by the Italian referee gave everything and for the last period appeared to be out on his feet, but still blasted his penalty into the roof of the net. Jordan James, a boy with so much more to learn, gave a superb performance before he was increasingly overwhelmed in the final stages of the 120 minutes. And the two leaders, Ben Davies, “Captain Courageous”, restricting the iconic Lewandowski to zero serious strikes on goal and still having time to maraud forward time and again. Ethan Ampadu, who gave not an inch in midfield and who was everywhere, who passed the ball like a Bobby Charlton and tackled like a Norman Hunter and took no nonsense from any Pole or any italian referee. No one, even those who were not so brilliant on the night it gave less than 100%.
There were though, as I have had to comment recently, failures of a tactical nature. We knew what the Poles would do. Don’t give an inch and hope for a moment of Lewandowski magic. We know the trick, it’s how he played when Bale was in his pomp. Of course, they tried manfully to get Moore sent off but Wales had the tools, if deployed properly to have won the match comfortably.
Squad Selection
On Friday night Rubin Colwill pushed the under 21s single handed to the top of their qualification group. He played so well he was added to the squad only to be left in the changing room without even a place on the bench. Colwill will sometimes fall over his own feet but on occasion can produce moments of magic that change games.
And where is Tom Lawrence – in Scotland- just why he has been exiled when his team made Rabi Matondo has been brought down from the north is a question one must ask.
Huddersfield may be struggling in the Championship, but most of their positive play comes from Sorba Thomas’s amazing left foot. You don’t have to like people to work with them. You also have to ask if Joe Allen would have returned if his revived form and Swansea had led Mr Page to ask him.
I think the point I’m making is that despite the limited nature of the talent pool there remain options that weren’t used.
Match Plan
Notoriously, as with the Danish debacle in the last Euros, Page and his coaching team are not flexible tactically. If Plan A works, as with Finland- great. If an astute coaching team from the other side sees and understands Plan A and changes the setup , Team Page doesn’t know how to move on to a revision. I will long recall Connor Roberts, when Plan A against Armenia had been sussed by the Armenian coaching team, running over to Page and telling him it wasn’t working. He changed nothing and Armenia scored every time they crossed the halfway line.
Plan A from the Finland match was a good plan to take into the Poland match but Brooks was not well and had to be replaced- wasting a place on the bench on someone too fragile to train is another question.
But Page didn’t go to Plan A with changed personnel although he had Dan James, Rabi Matondo and Nathan Broadhead who could have filled the Brooks role in the Finland pattern. He changed the plan and went to the Kiefer Moore lone striker plan.
That was a shame as playing with the main central striker took away a degree of fluidity that was so effective against Finland .
Substitution Strategy
The substitution strategy was seriously flawed. In the second-half the two holding midfielders were gradually worn down and Poland had more control which meant the attacking capacity was blunted. Likewise, the lone striker was gradually being played out of contention.
Changes needed to be made from about 60 minutes. Jordan James needed to be replaced by someone able to exert a greater degree of control and compete physically. Of those on the bench Sheehan or Ramsey were the obvious choices, but Ramsey was only there because he’s a nice chap not because he’s fit enough to play. Sheehan is a third tier player but when fit – which we assume he is- has the technical capacity to flourish in Championship football and at this international level. James should have replaced Moore allowing Johnson, James and Wilson to exploit the waning Polish energy levels. If the data showed that Johnson was physically drained then he could have been replaced by Matondo or Broadhead.
When Connor Roberts left injured – perhaps the change should have been made earlier as he was struggling for some time- to replace him with the ailing David Brooks was a bizarre decision. Why have Jay Dasilva there when he is a defender playing all the time in a high-level Championship team. It was the moment to introduce him to the battle.
As it was moving Dan James to full back/wing back was capable only of blunting the already tiring attacking forces. The decisions made during the match contributed to the outcome. Finally, Rob Page’s qualification luck ran out.
None of the players deserves anything but praise, even David Brooks who should have declared himself unfit and watched from the stand made his wrong decision from the right motivation.
Lessons to be learned.
The manager has and will continue to have a long-term contract. If he was sacked and paid off the under 21s will have to train on a local park pitch and stay in youth hostels for away games.
Mr Page is a very nice man and a very competent coach. I don’t know him but friends who do speak very highly of him. The players in the squad also think very highly of him.
The FAW and specifically Noel Mooney have to help him to be a more effective international team manager. The team around him needs to be revamped. He needs a right-hand man who has the footballing analytical intelligence to read a match and help Mr Page use his undoubted man management skills to the best effect. A medical team that allowed Ramsey to be a squad member and a clearly unwell Brooks to be on the bench has serious questions to answer. Modern football demands that a player be like a carefully tuned machine and if things are not perfect then failure is ensured.
Having over 100 caps and having been Gareth Bale’s best mate was no reason to give Chris Gunter a coaching post. Mr Mooney has the duty to give Mr Page the tools to be the best manager he can be, whether he likes it or not.
There’s a busy autumn Nations League programme and success there will do much to ease the pain of not going to Germany. World Cup qualification will need a good squad firing on all cylinders. We have a good squad and World Cup qualification is by no means impossible.
